Blog
arrow-right
Managers vs creators

Managers vs creators

Every content marketer eventually faces a choice: build the machine, or write the message it sends.

From Reads to Leads is a newsletter for writers who want more. It's about marketing. Strategy. Positioning. Operations. Results. And yes, it talks about writing too. But through a marketing lens. If this was sent to you, subscribe here so you don't miss the next email.

In today's newsletter:

  • The manager path
  • The creator path
  • How to choose yours

Manager or Creator?

This week, during a mentorship session, a content manager asked me: "What career growth opportunities are actually available in content marketing?"

Great question! I wish more people would ask that.

Here’s what I said: Do you want to be a manager or a creator?

The manager path

Managers zoom out. They build systems for others to follow. 

They jump from meeting to meeting, message to message, email to email.

Their time gets sliced into 60-minute chunks. Their focus, spread thin across priorities. Deep work? It's not for managers.

“The manager's schedule is for bosses. It's embodied in the traditional appointment book, with each day cut into one-hour intervals.”

Paul Graham in “Maker’s Schedule, Manager’s Schedule”

Manager's goal? Get the best out of their team. Their struggle? Making progress with as little time investment as possible. Doing this well means constantly making tradeoffs between the work, the people, and the financial pressures.

Where does work satisfaction come from for managers? 

Their decisions. If they lead to growth. But the results take time and aren't always visible in the moment. Which means managers can go through entire weeks thinking, “I worked my ass off and still feel like I didn’t do anything.”

The creator path

Creators zoom in. They do the work. And that work requires focus. 

“When you're operating on the maker's schedule, meetings are a disaster. A single meeting can blow a whole afternoon, by breaking it into two pieces, each too small to do anything hard in.” 

Paul Graham

Creators hate context switching. 

Their goal? Create something beautiful.

Their struggle? “Good enough” isn’t good enough. They want to create the best version possible. That requires time and focus to master their craft: how it flows, where it breaks, what sings, and what falls flat. That demands immersion.

Where does work satisfaction come from for creators?

It comes from knowing that they have accomplished something. Like getting their article published, and seeing their copy materialize on a new website.

David Ogilvy or Ann Handley?

David Ogilvy, the legendary ad man, started as a creator but built and ran Ogilvy & Mather. He is a manager. He managed to scale creative through systems and teams. 

If you dream of building an empire and leading a team → look to Ogilvy

Ann Handley, the author of “Everybody Writers,” is a creator. She writes, teaches, and inspires other creators. She built authority through writing, not managing teams.

If you want to create timeless work and make an influence through your ideas → look to Handley

Would I rather build the machine or write the message it sends?

You can do both, by the way. 

Managers also make things — strategy is a creative act.

Creators also manage, because making anything usually involves people, deadlines, and collaboration.

But which one feels more you

  • If you’re a manager, start learning cross-functional skills like strategy, operations, analytics, and leadership
  • If you’re a creator, start building your body of work and finding your voice.

To do something well, you have to like it.

See you next week

 

So are you a manager or a creator? 

I'm a creator for sure. 

Yesterday, I drew this image of my son in the diary I write about him. It made me feel accomplished all day.

Kate

P.S. If we aren't connected already, follow me on LinkedIn and Instagram. If you like this newsletter, please refer your friends.

P.P.S. Need a hand with content? Fix your mediocrity problem with Zmist & Copy

Read also:

blog thumbnail
people
Copywriter vs Content Writer vs Technical Writer vs Blogger vs UX Writer and More: Who to Hire?

What's the difference between copywriters and a whole bunch of other creative specialists that have something to do with writing and marketing? Time to figure it out!

blog thumbnail
people
What Metrics Do In-House Content Writers Need to Track?

Do you find numbers intimidating? They're actually a lot more relatable than you may think! KPIs can help you measure your content writers' performance, but they also help you foster their morale and professional growth.